Jeffrey Hicks

Jeffrey Hicks

Platform Eng @R360

State Management Comparison: Redux Stores vs GenServers

Perplexity research exploring architectural similarities and differences between React Redux Stores and Phoenix GenServers for state management

By Agent Hicks • Aug 24, 2025 • perplexity-export

Both React Redux Stores and Phoenix GenServers serve as centralized state management solutions, though they operate in fundamentally different environments. Here’s a systematic comparison of their key properties:

TermDefinitionReact Redux StoresPhoenix GenServer
State ContainerCentralized location for application stateSingle JavaScript object treeProcess with internal state in memory
State UpdatesMethod for modifying stateActions dispatched to reducersMessages sent to handle_call/handle_cast
ImmutabilityWhether state is directly modifiedEnforced - new state objects createdFunctional updates return new state
State AccessHow components/processes read stateuseSelector hooks or connect()GenServer.call() for synchronous access
Async OperationsHandling side effects and async logicRedux Thunk/Saga middlewarehandle_cast for async, handle_call for sync
SubscriptionsNotification of state changesComponents re-render on state changePubSub or Phoenix.Channel broadcasts
PredictabilityAbility to trace state changesAction log provides clear historyMessage log via handle_* callbacks
PersistenceSaving state across restartsManual serialization to localStorageBuilt-in via init/1 and terminate/2
ConcurrencyHandling multiple simultaneous operationsSingle-threaded, actions queuedActor model with message queue
State IsolationScope of state accessGlobal store accessible everywhereProcess-isolated, explicit access
Time TravelAbility to replay state changesRedux DevTools enable replayNot built-in, but achievable with event sourcing
Error HandlingManaging failures in state updatesTry-catch in reducers/middlewareSupervisor trees and restart strategies
PerformanceOptimization strategiesMemoization, normalized stateProcess pooling, ETS tables
TestingApproach to testing state logicPure reducer functions easy to testMock GenServer calls or test in isolation
ScalingHandling increased loadHorizontal scaling requires external stateMultiple GenServer processes, distributed

The architectural similarities stem from both being message-based systems that centralize state management, though GenServers operate in a concurrent, fault-tolerant environment while Redux operates in a single-threaded browser context.