CanCan vs Phoenix Scopes
Perplexity research exploring the differences between CanCan's accessible_by method in Rails and Phoenix Scopes for authorization patterns
Explanation of Phoenix 1.8 scopes pattern for centralizing user context and permission management for better security and maintainability
The Phoenix team introduced “scopes” in Phoenix 1.8 as a recommended pattern (not a library) to improve security and maintainability by centralizing user context and permission management.
Traditional approach requires passing user-specific parameters (user ID, org ID, etc.) to every context function, which becomes unmanageable as complexity grows.
A scope is a struct containing all user context:
Instead of multiple parameters, pass one scope struct as the first parameter to context functions.
The Phoenix team highly recommends this pattern for any app handling user-specific data, making permission management simpler and more secure as complexity increases.
Perplexity research exploring the differences between CanCan's accessible_by method in Rails and Phoenix Scopes for authorization patterns